Shylock in william shakespeare's the merchant of venice by the end of act 4 scene 1, my view of shylock is a man who wishes to get revenge at society by trying to take the flesh of a venetian all of my familiarity with the play was based on hearsay, and for some reason i got the idea in my heads that it was a tragedy. Although he had many reasons for revenge, were they justified shylock hated and did not respect antonio as he had injured and insulted him in the past and made it very clear that he would in the future as he says i am as like to call thee [ dog] again, / to spit on thee again, to spurn thee too shylock says. To a large extent, whether or not shylock is justified in seeking revenge or not is up to each individual reader i am sure that there are plenty of people out there that believe shylock's desire for revenge is completely justified those people believe in an eye for an eye antonio is undercutting shylock's profit margins by not. I think shylock's blind passion for revenge is jusifiedshylock was disrespected and insulted by antonio and gang on various occasions as explained by him antonio used to call him a beggar whereas the othersabused his religionhis heritage and religion made him instinctively hate christiansshylock. Own child, each seeks to revenge the wrong done him, and each falls in the shylock launcelot's real reason for entering the service of bassanio was to get rare new liveries (ibid, 100) and bassanio himself, though he dislikes shylock, doubts, nevertheless colored lambs, so might he also be justified in thriving on. To take a measure of revenge, shylock forgoes charging any interest on antonio's loan and instead sets the bond at one pound of antonio's flesh when antonio's ships are the message seems to be that because he and his people are oppressed, shylock was somewhat justified in his actions shylock's significance as a. What exactly was jessica's real reason and motive for running away also, as tubal told shylock, jessica was wasting and spending all of her father's money and jewels without any good reason or purpose there is no justification for wasting her father's money jessica just did what she could to hurt her father, or else she.
It is justifiable yea revenge makes you feel a little better but after a while when you have time to look back on what you have done it makes you feel horrible karma does come back but one does not cause karma because karma causes itself think before you act be the bigger person report post report post like reply. If you prick us, do we not bleed if you tickle us, do we not laugh if you poison us, do we not die and if you wrong us, shall we not revenge ~ shylock from merchant of venice shylock was more a victim than a villain he was continuously mo. Get an answer for ' justify shylock's demand for revenge against antonio' and find homework help for other the merchant of venice questions at enotes.
Causes controversy in the play is the fact that he is jewish which has left many people with different views on him the discussion of shylock is always a understanding of the play and to make a justified comment on shylock, we must take the history background and its author into account in the following. (1,3, 126-129) this is only one example, but this was a contributing factor in shylock's extreme search for revenge he believes that revenge is right because christians engage in revenge shylock uses christian teachings to justify his vengeful actions he exposes christian hypocrisy in his “hath not a jew” speech.
Kean and irving presented a shylock justified in wanting his revenge adler's shylock evolved over the years he played the role, first as a stock shakespearean villain, then as a man whose better nature was overcome by a desire for revenge, and finally as a man who operated not from revenge but from pride in a 1902. He is a wealthy, moneylending jew who practices usury he's revenge is justified for many reasons, these reasons include him being abused for being a jew and a moneylender at the same time another reason is that antonio prevents him from doing business as he loans money interest free shylock was. Shylock's hatred towards antonio is quite apparent throughout the play, there are many reasons why he hates antonio, the fact that antonio curses him at every opportunity is way down on his list but it reinforces shylock's prejudice driving him to revenge, and as with everything the main reasons are the.
His evil must have some profound motivation, and that motivation is the evil done to him shylock is not an ogre, letting lose harm and disaster without reason he was wronged first the fact that his revenge far outweighs that initial evil is what makes him a villain beneath shylock' villainy, the concept of evil for evil runs as a. In venice, the duke opens antonio's trial by saying that he pities antonio because shylock is an inhuman wretch uncapable of pity (413–4) the duke has antonio's gentleness is contrasted with shylock's refusal to be swayed from enacting his revenge she declines on the grounds that she must get back to padua.
Shylock implies that the reason for these hatreds and the need to destroy lies in affection, or an emotion or feeling (oed), again inadequate explanation to justify his goals his feelings of dislike regarding antonio do not logically validate his desire to murder him as humans we have learned to separate. Two scenes after the wilderness of monkeys, shylock has animals on his mind again “thou calledst me dog before thou had a cause,” he reminds antonio, “but since i am a dog, beware my fangs” so, yes, though all that's feral disheartens and demoralises him, he will put on a feral disposition in an act that. Shylock's defense to bait fish withal: if it will feed nothing else, it will feed my revenge he hath disgrac'd me and hind'red me half a million laugh'd at my losses, mock'd at my gains, scorned my nation, thwarted my bargains, cooled my friends, heated mine enemies and what's his reason i am a jew hath not a jew eyes. Everything you ever wanted to know about shylock in the merchant of venice, written by masters of this stuff just for you you could argue that shylock's hatred and desire for vengeance is a natural result of his circumstances in the 2004 film adaptation is shylock just being hateful, or is his disdain justifiable we know.